Hardware: two cameras, of two types
Both the smartphones come with dual back cameras, and dual LED flashes but the combination of sensors that the two have are completely different. The Xiaomi A1 comes with a 12-megapixel + 12-megapixel RGB plus telephoto sensor, that offers you 2X optical zoom while the Moto G5s Plus features a 13-megapixel + 13-megapixel RBG plus monochrome sensor, which claims to offer better details and color. The camera combination on the MI A1 has slightly smaller apertures (f/2.0 and f/2.6 for the telephoto) and compared to the f/2.0 on the dual snappers on the Moto. In terms of selfie cameras too, the G5s Plus has the edge, with an 8.0-megapixel snapper with a flash while the one on the Mi A1 is a 5.0-megapixel one. Regarding sheer hardware specs, we think that the force is with the Moto G5s Plus here, as both devices are powered by similar chipsets (Qualcomm Snapdragon 625) and come with 4GB RAM/ 64 GB storage combinations.
UI: Feature rich Vs. (largely) Minimalistic
In the past, Moto has been known to offer a stock Android experience while Xiaomi has been known for its MIUI interface. But the story is a little different in this case. This time Xiaomi A1 comes as part of the Android One initiative, offering pure stock Android (at least this is what they say). On the surface that would seem to level out the playing field, but if you thought things were going to be pretty simple, they, in fact, are not. For both companies have played around with their camera apps, allegedly because the stock Android camera as of now (both run on Nougat) does not have features for dual cameras! While the Xiaomi A1 mostly comes with stock Android, the camera is where the company has stepped away from pure Android, and we would not be wrong if we told you that opening up the camera app on the Xiaomi A1 pretty much takes us back to MIUI. The base has the gallery icon, the shutter button and the video/photo switch icon from left to right. Just above it is the icon for different modes that offer more than ten modes (effects) including Color Pop, Rustic, Black And White amongst others, and right next to it is the Option button that takes you to the Option menu which has nine different shooting options including Panorama, Tilt-Shift, Group Selfies, and Manual. Right by its side is the camera switch option that lets you switch between the selfie camera and primary camera. On the northern end, we have the flash icon, the stereo (portrait) mode, and the HDR mode. The interface offers a number of different shooting options, and this obviously allows you to play more with the camera. Moto has also tweaked the camera app for the Moto G5s Plus, but it comes closer to the stock Android aesthetic – it is minimalistic and does not overwhelm you. The base of the display has the three basic on-screen touch buttons. Above them, you have the camera switch icon that will let you switch from primary camera to secondary camera, right next to it is the shutter button, then a video/ photograph icon and finally, there is the mode button which has like four modes which are camera, panorama, depth enabled and professional mode (the depth-enabled mode is a special touch, and the phone also has a depth-editor which lets you play around with the background). On top are the HDR icon, the flash icon, the timer and the night mode button. Swiping right will take you to settings while swiping left will take you to the gallery. There is actually nothing outstanding about Moto G5s Plus’s camera app but the ones who prefer just point and shooting are going to pretty much love it. So which works better? We think we like the Xiaomi A1 camera interface more because first you can simply use it as a point and shooter if you wish and second you be all artsy if you want with the options available. And for us, having the option to play with the camera is more important than having no options at all. So with Xiaomi A1, you have the best of both worlds. Stock Android fans and those who prefer simplicity will, however, prefer the Moto G5s Plus.
All right: say cheese…and shoot!
That is about the sensors and software on the two devices. Now to the real test – how they perform. We think both the smartphone cameras had their positives and negatives. We think that the Moto G5s Plus produced pictures with better details while the Xiaomi A1 reproduced better color. While there were no major faults with any of the camera and both are among the best in the price segment (and better than some of their more expensive competitors), there were a few areas where both stumbled. Notably, both the phones had their share of lags and stutters. The Xiaomi A1’s camera took a couple of seconds to launch from the lock screen and had visible lags while processing pictures. The Moto G5s Plus had its share of troubles as well – it took time to click pictures in depth enabled mode. Note: In all the pictures below, Xiaomi Mi A1 is on the left while Moto G5s Plus is on the right. For full resolution pictures, click here for Mi A1 and click here for Moto G5s Plus.
In pictures taken outdoors, the Xiaomi A1 produced more realistic colors while the pictures taken by the Moto G5s Plus seemed a bit oversaturated (the colors had seemed more realistic initially but have got more oversaturated following a software update). But in pictures taken indoors, the story changed a little. The colors on the Xiaomi A1’s pictures seemed a little faded while those on the G5s Plus appeared more accurate. In the detailing section, the results were again very close. Both the phone cameras performed well in this segment, but we think the Moto G5s Plus had a slight edge over the Xiaomi A1. We could see the wrinkles on the flowers and bubbles on our coffee just a bit better on the G5s Plus even though there was not any staggering difference between the two cameras – spotting the better one at a single glance will be tough. In our review, we had mentioned that the G5s Plus handled glare poorly. Well, guess what, the Xiaomi A1 competes with the G5s Plus in that department. In this particular aspect, we think these two are equally bad and cannot handle glare to save a drowning man. The G5s Plus and the A1 both did a decent job when it comes to low light performance. The noise levels were not unacceptable (for this price point – you do not get Pixel and iPhone performances at this level), and detail was decent, but we think, the Moto G5s Plus performs a bit better in low light than the A1. Sometimes the shots by the A1 got blurry while the shots by the Moto G5s Plus seemed fairly focused. And better colored as well. The A1 takes the crown for those who want to zoom in. 2x might not seem a lot to DSLR users, but to smartphone users, it is a fair bit. There is no such option available in the Moto G5s Plus. When it comes to selfies, both the cameras had a fair bit of noise in the pictures, but we think, we prefer the Moto G5s Plus over the Xiaomi A1 because the selfies taken by the Moto G5s Plus had better detail and color as well. Plus the selfies taken by the Xiaomi A1 appeared to be a little beautified even when the mode was off. And yes, we saved the most discussed factor for last – the bokeh on the two phones. The Moto G5s Plus has a Depth-Enabled mode while the Xiaomi A1 offers two different modes for bokeh, the good old tilt-shift which is there on mostly all Xiaomi devices and is largely software based and the Stereo mode which is the hardware game. In this department, the Xiaomi A1 wins the competition hands down. The pictures taken by the Stereo mode had better-defined subjects, and the background was well blurred out, and the pictures seemed very sharp. Whereas in the case of the Moto G5s Plus, the Depth enabled mode seemed a bit software driven and also seemed sluggish (we were told this was because the cameras capture an image which has so much detail that the focus can be moved anywhere) – the edges of some of our subjects that had to be in focus were blurred while there was bit of the background that was in focus in some shots. All in all, it seemed a little inconsistent. On the other hand, the Moto G5s Plus allows you to take pretty much a depth enabled shot anywhere and also allows you to play around with the amount of bokeh you want, while the Stereo mode on the Mi A1 determines what kind of shot you take, telling you to move a bit forward and back and so on, just as on the iPhones. The smaller aperture on the Mi A1, however, also means that Stereo Mode does not always work in relatively low light condition. The Depth Editor on the Moto G5s Plus allows you to do more with the background in Depth-Enabled snaps, but all said and done, we think that the A1 gets the win here – it does bokeh better!
Mi + Moto (A1 + G5s Plus) = the perfect camera equation
So which one gets the budget dual camera crown? Well it is a pretty close battle, and both cameras have their positives and negatives – one is good in some departments, while the other is good in others. All said and done; we would prefer the Xiaomi A1 over the Moto G5s Plus- that Stereo mode and the optical zoom does tilt matters in its favor, as does the feature-rich interface, and better color reproduction. But the Moto G5s Plus has its own plus points; it is great with detail, takes better selfies and has a simpler UI, and a far more flexible depth of field feature. The perfect phone camera will have the best of these two phones – two sensors, one monochrome, one RGB (with telephoto), with relatively large f/2.0 apertures, and a UI with plenty of shooting options, even while letting you do more with bokeh. It is a good fight, this. And we are going for the A1, but by a very slim margin indeed. But those opting for a Moto G5s Plus will not have much to regret in the camera department either.
